Is this nationalism?

They way some see it, the people of Japan are a bunch of unthinking nationalistic mind-numbed robots, programmed by decades of propaganda-laden textbooks and history-distorting manga to fall behind the nation’s right-wing leaders when called upon to take up arms against its neighbors.

Well if that were indeed true, one would expect that Japanese national ire would be running pretty high right now against China and South Korea over the abuse the two countries have been heaping upon Japan over the past few months. In fact, Japanese public opinion seems to be laying the blame for all the consulate trashing, business destroying, and flag burning of late at the feet of. . . Japanese Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi.

According to a survey conducted by the Mainichi Shimbun, 76% of the people polled say that Koizumi is not doing enough to improve Japan’s strained relations with its neighbors. Only 16% say Koizumi is doing enough.

Respondents also saw the following as the causes of anti-Japan demonstrations in China.

  • Chinese domestic situation (34%)
  • Japanese government’s interpretation of history concerning Japan’s invasion (26%)
  • Koizumi’s visits to Yasukuni Shrine (13%)
  • Japan’s bid for UNSC membership (11%)

8 Responses to “Is this nationalism?”

Ray Said:

I think some readers would be interested in this link from BBC, as I was. After interviewing Chinese citizens about the whole textbook/protest ordeal, they went ahead and did the same with Japanese, as they should have.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/shared/spl/hi/pop_ups/05/asia_pac_japanese_views_on_china/html/1.stm

Hope that link works for everybody. I wish I could find the link for the Chinese part but I can’t seem to find it on BBC anymore.

Mr Pink Said:

Excellent link. Thanks, Ray.

Simon World Said:

Japan/China tensions (Updated April 20th)

Note: I am adding to previous coverage, starting from the Update below. The previous coverage is below the fold, in chronological order. The Huanxi riots are covered in another post. Update April 20th * Winston Marshall has a typically thorough look at…

Joe Said:

Here’s the link to the Chinese part of that BBC feature Ray couldn’t find – http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/shared/spl/hi/pop_ups/05/asia_pac_chinese_views_on_japan/html/1.stm

King Ko-ree-u Said:

The URL for the main article is incorrect or has been changed. Anyone have a correct URL?

JP Said:

I found the changed link and corrected it in our article. It should work now.

Kristofer Said:

The link to Mainichi is incorrect. This is a really old post so I don’t really expect it to be corrected, but is sure would be nice.

JP Said:

Publications often change their links with time. The Mainichi link was correct when we originally published the post last April.

Leave a Reply

Design: Dao By Design | Powered by WordPress