What do the simple folk do?

Princess Sayako, Emperor Akihito’s daughter, is going to be married this fall. Since her husband-to-be is a commoner, she will lose her royal status. But for all that she will ostensibly be losing, Sayako, who is 36, will be gaining the privilege to do some things she’s never done before. These include getting a drivers’ license, having the right to vote, having a last name, getting her own telephone, and going shopping for herself.

Here is an official’s explanation as reported by Reuters on the difficulties presented by a member of the Japanese Imperial family getting a driver’s license:

“In general, members of the Imperial Family, such as the Emperor, do not drive outside the palace grounds because they might cause bother for the public,” said a spokesman for the Imperial Household Agency. Providing security for royals on wheels would also be a problem, he added.

To put that less diplomatically, it’s not that their driving would bother the public, it’s that the response by others to their driving that would bother the public. The Japanese media is among the world’s most tenacious and obnoxious, and the number of useless people assigned to follow the royal family wherever they go would soar from the current horde to an unmanageable mob tailing the unfortunate driver even on the most mundane of errands.

Princess Sayako

The article reports that Sayako is learning on the palace grounds. Most Japanese go to a driving school before getting their license, but that would be unimaginable for the Emperor’s immediate family, no matter how much they might enjoy mingling with the common folk. The media would camp out in tree houses to film every second the princess spent behind the wheel and broadcast it endlessly on television, with groups of self-proclaimed experts and third-rate showbiz personalities commenting on her skills when shifting from first gear into second.

She will not be the first among her siblings to get a driver’s license, however. The first was her older brother, Prince Akishino (also widely known as The One Who Doesn’t Comb His Hair; see photo below). Akishino fancied himself quite the lad, and in his younger days used to tool around Tokyo in a yellow Volkswagen beetle. (The choice of a foreign car is significant; he couldn’t drive a Japanese car and therefore seem to favor one domestic automaker over another.) Akishino was filmed taking his father, the Emperor, for a spin.

Commonplace stuff for most people, but this was a bold new step for the Japanese Imperial family. It is difficult to comprehend their lack of personal freedom. Emperor Akihito was adamant that he wanted to be involved with his wife, the Empress, in rearing their children. He, as his ancestors before him, seldom saw his parents growing up, as he was essentially raised by palace functionaries. Akihito made a point when playing with his children of letting them jump off the lower step of an exterior staircase to the ground. He had not been allowed to play games like that for fear that he might get injured, and he certainly wasn’t allowed any time for frivolities with his father. Nevertheless, his son and heir, Crown Prince Naruhito, likely isn’t allowed to drive as his brother and sister are.

The One Who Doesn't Comb His Hair

The Imperial Household Agency, part of the Japanese government, controls every aspect of the public life of the Imperial family, and a large part of their private life. The agency determines how their time is spent in official duties, where they go, what they wear, who they see, and, for the most part, what they say. This is exacerbated by the conservative and secretive nature of the agency and its members. One look at their mugs and you can see the little cartoon balloons sprouting over their heads containing the words, “You can’t do that.”

Crown Prince Naruhito caused a tsunami last year when he hijacked a press conference, usually a dull affair, to complain that his wife Masako wasn’t permitted by the Imperial Household Agency to take a more active role in promoting Japan overseas. (Before her marriage she worked in the Foreign Ministry; she also speaks several languages.) As most public statements from the Imperial family are the very definition of bland, Naruhito’s open criticism of the Agency was almost shocking and was dissected in detail by the mass media. It definitely shocked his parents, the Emperor and Empress, because he hadn’t discussed it with them beforehand. Father and son have some difficulty communicating, regardless of how well they get along; they have to make appointments in advance to see each other, and they just can’t pick up the phone and call because they don’t have personal telephones.

The members of the Imperial family themselves would like to lead a more modern lifestyle, and many Japanese share their wish. The distance they have to travel to approach the modern age must seem enormous to them, however, as they deal with constraints that are tantamount to confinement in a Medieval dungeon. Here’s hoping that Sayako will adjust to her new status as a commoner with a minimum of fuss and thrive–and drive–in relative anonymity. While she might be losing her royal status, she just might be gaining her life.

7 Responses to “What do the simple folk do?”

teh_oc Said:

re: Crown Princess Masako, there seems to be a divergence in her coverage in the western press vs the perceptions of those in Japan. Like, this whole idea that she’s some diplomat. She wasn’t, and rumors fly that she only received a coveted Foreign Ministry job due to her father’s influence (he was a top Foreign Ministry diplomat). And her interpretation of “promoting Japan overseas” really means “going to Western European countries and hanging with European royals”. Note that the Crown Prince and Princess had a great opportunity to “promote Japan overseas” when the South Asian tsunami struck, but they hardly budged.

JoeSchmoe Said:

Fascinating. I had no idea what an insulated life the Japanese royalty lead.

Ampontan Said:

It’s not just Western Europe; the Imperial family is just as likely to associate with the representatives of an Asian or African country most people couldn’t find on a map as they are with Queen Elizabeth. Perhaps even more so; there are more of those kinds of countries, and it’s part of their job. The Emperor, constitutionally, is the symbol of the nation, but the choice of how that symbolism is expressed is left to others.

As for Masako’s connections, well, welcome to Japan. Most of the high-level people in the government got there because their fathers got there before them. (Koizumi’s father was a Cabinet minister.) Ditto for business, the arts, you name it. Ceramicists and kabuki actors pass their title from father to son, though of course they begin training from, as they say in Japan, the age of zero.

As for the tsunami, the Imperial family goes where the Imperial Household Agency tells them to go. They certainly go to the scene of Japanese disasters. I don’t recall any of the European royal houses being represented there, however, and Indonesia, for example, was a Dutch colony. Perhaps I missed it.

Two Cents Said:

One royal lady who also married a commoner said, “The realization that I had become a commoner hit me when the car that carried me stopped at a red light for the first time in my life.”

As for Princess Masako’s plight, the only practical solution I see to curing her mental illness is a divorce. If there’s a problem with the next Crown Princess Aiko having a commoner for a mother, then the Crown should be passed down to Prince Akishino’s line. He pleasantly surprised many Japanese when he criticized his brother saying that the duty of a royal is to do what the people ask of him and not to put forth personal preferences over duty. Contrary to popular belief, he may actually be the one cut out for the role. His wife, Princess Kiko, is just as qualified as Princess Masako as she is also highly educated and fluent in English, German, and sign language. (Her family lived for several years in Vienna and later in Pennsylvania.) And most important, Princess Kiko genuinely seems to enjoy what she is doing. The Crown Prince’s comment was disastrous to his popularity. He may not have realized it, but what he said mainly translates into, “We don’t like our present duties inside Japan, I and my former diplomat wife are above these menial tasks.” Imagine how the people at facilities they has visited must feel upon hearing such a comment.

Ampontan, I believe teh oc’s comment on “mingling with Western royals” points to the observation made by some Japanese that Princess Masako’s condition always seems to improve enough when meeting with Western royals, but never when the occasion calls for meetings with non-western royals, thus resulting in malicious whispers that her wish for a more diplomatically active role must mean parties with Western royals.

Ampontan Said:

Two cents:

I don’t think “the people” ask the imperials to do anything. The Imperial Household Agency tells them what to do, with little or no oversight, and they are bureaucrats beyond the reach of anything “the people” could or would suggest.

As for Kiko enjoying her role, it is considerably less taxing than Masako’s. Also, she has never had the added burden of being forced to produce a male heir. And I do mean forced. Masako had one botched pregnancy before giving birth. The first time the issue regarding women on the throne came up, one prominent politician said it wasn’t necessary to deal with it yet because there was still plenty of time for her to produce a boy.

I don’t know if you know people with fertility problems who have tried to conceive, but the treatments can difficult, taxing, and painful for both men and women, particularly women, and they don’t have 100 million people and an obnoxious media and political class breathing down their necks.

Also, don’t forget that the current Empress has had her own health problems in the past that were attributed to problems with the Imperial Household Agency, who seem to have practiced yomeibiri on her because she, like Masako was not a commoner.

Masako knew about this before she got married, and her husband promised to protect her. I give a lot of credit to Naruhito for having a pair and overcoming the countless excuses he could have used for being quiet and actually going public.

For his part, Akishino didn’t have the same upbringing as his older brother, as he was not expected to sit on the throne, and so has had a life freer of a lot of psychological pressue. Heck, he even had a driver’s license, something his brother could never dream of. He also was widely rumored to have bonked everything in a skirt during his younger days, which also was not an option easily available to his brother. It’s just my personal opinion, but he’s always struck me as something of a dork.

The rumors about Masako getting better when dealing with Westerners may or may not be true, but I would not put it past the IHA to make them up and spread them to maintain the upper hand.

Two Cents Said:


No, the people don’t directly get to ask anything of the royals, but requests are made by various organizations through the IHA. The IHA selects what they think is appropriate, and the royals simply go wherever they’re directed to. However, their presence is powerful. Any facility they visit will be heavily funded to prepare for the visit, meaning money for badly needed renovations will be given, and so the requests are actually like pleas for funding that otherwise go ignored by government officials. The visits also promote public awareness on social issues. The mere presence of the Emperor still means a lot to elderly people and a majority of the Japanese feel that they are special, and such simple sentiments are what support the foundation of the royal family now. That is what Prince Akishino was saying.

I know that treatment of infertility is mentally and physically draining, and although I sympathize with Princess Masako as an individual, what to do about the royal lineage is another problem altogether. The present situation could have been foreseen when the GHQ slashed the number of royal households to 5. Today, when royals no longer have multiple wives, the chances of passing down the lineage diminish. Should Japan bring and end to the 125 reigns passed down through fraternal lineage? (I am fully aware that there are likely to be breaks already in the bloodline, but officially, it’s not acknowledged.) Or do we reinstate some ex-royals? In the past, there were female emperors, but they all took the throne because the next male heir was too young. The throne in all cases was returned to the holder of the fraternal lineage. What will entitle them to the throne if they are not going to carry on this tradition? They will become no more special than an ordinary Japanese family, except for the fact that they live in the palace and have expenses paid for by taxpayers. I don’t think it will take much time before someone starts to campaign for the abolishment of the family (waste of tax, waste of land.) and the majority of the Japanese not really caring what happens because their effective end had already been brought about. Actually, the worst case scenario may be the placement of a proper heir (with the proper lineage) at the head of a coup in times of distress for the country. Propaganda like, “Goddess Amaterasu is mad that her descendants no longer rule Japan,” may very well work.

As for Prince Akishino being a dork, that is what I meant when I wrote “Contrary to popular opinion.” He seems like a typical second son, carefree and irresponsible. That is why I was surprised when he criticized his brother. And as for Princess Kiko being freer from stress, probably. But she doesn’t fail to put a smile on her face even with the busy schedule brought about by the absent Crown couple, which may become even busier with Princess Sayako married off and the Emperor sick. That counts.

lightfield2007 Said:

In my opinion, which is as a non-Japanese foreigner, it sounds as if most of the problems that the royal family faces are created by the Imperial Household Agency. Why not get rid of the IHA? Why do they hold such absolute power – it is as if they are more powerful than the royal family, themselves.

I do not believe that ANY of us are qualified to criticize the royals when we have no idea of what it must be like to be them.

The IHA should be under the royal family and under the will of the Japanese people. It should not be permitted to operate without any oversight or review. Absolute power is inherently corrupt, and it seems to me that the IHA is just that.

Peace and Every Good from North Carolina.

Leave a Reply

Design: Dao By Design | Powered by WordPress