Freedom of Speech In Japan
There is freedom of speech and freedom of assembly in Japan, but it also matters where those freedoms are exercised. According to the Japan Times:
Venerated by militarists and marinated in over a century of militarism and war, Yasukuni Shrine may well be Japan’s least friendly venue for a demonstration by pacifists.
Still, every Aug. 15, a motley crew of Christians, radicals and antiwar campaigners come here to stage what has traditionally been a token protest against visits to the shrine by prominent politicians.
The activists range in age from 19 to 90 and seldom carry anything more dangerous than white flags and placards, which is why they were stunned last month when the police waded in and arrested six of their members.
Dressed in full riot gear, the police behaved aggressively, swinging batons, feet and fists against people who were posing no threat to anyone, claim the activists.
The protesters claim they were jostled, kicked and punched as they tried to get to the shrine, where they intended to shout antiwar slogans during the traditional one-minute’s silence at noon; four — including a law student and a musician — were grabbed and held with the other two arrestees, without charge, for 12 days.
As always on Aug. 15, the shrine was serenaded by martial music from dozens of ultranationalist sound trucks and heavily ringed by thousands of police.
Hardly a venue, in other words, likely to be seriously threatened by at most 500 mostly middle-aged pacifists, but the authorities disagree.
The Yasukuni arrests follow the successful prosecution of Masaki Kinoshita last year after he sprayed a public toilet wall in Suginami-ku in Tokyo with antiwar slogans. The prosecuting judge in the case said that Kinoshita had “spoiled the beauty of the toilet, making users uncomfortable and unhappy.”
Yes, we don’t want anyone to be uncomfortable or unhappy in Japan…
September 7th, 2005 at 2:29 pmVandalizing a toilet seems a peculiar way to become a free-speech martyr… http://japundit.com/wp-images/smilies/icon_rolleyes.gif
why is this guy in the story again?
September 12th, 2005 at 9:47 amAbove comment by me.
September 12th, 2005 at 9:49 amdo yall have the right to life, libertiy
February 11th, 2006 at 3:39 ami must agree with the police in that freedom of speech has its bounderies, especially concerning places that have value to a group of people. There’s freedom of speech and then there’s disrespect, and that type of speech should be governmentally controlled. There’s a time and place for everything, and i don’t believe this was the time and place for a protest. It’s a shrine in honor of the military, not for or against it. I suppose you could possibly say that it is pro-militial strength, but that is simply in the best interests of the public and to protect them.
March 15th, 2006 at 12:26 pmprague101
What you fail to mention is that this war shrine entombs some of Japan’s top war brass and criminals.
It would be easy enough to hold ceremonies that involve the Diet members at a shine that doesn’t house so much bad blood.
Imagine Germany paying homage to the war dead where Hitler would have been placed. That is the feeling of many of the Chinese and Koreans that complain.
Freedom of speech has no limits and or boundary for anyone! If this were on private property, then trespassing would have come into play, just like the above case of vandalism which is not free speech.
By even thinking that governmental control is good in the most minute form goes against the essence of what freedom is.
PS, freedom of speech is and was created for the people to speak out against a bad government also.
Why would you want the person putting the chains on you to also stitch your mouth shut at the same time.
try to avoid failed logic
February 8th, 2010 at 1:28 pm[...] slander in general. Japan, on the other hand, only seems to crack down on incidents related to the controversial Yasukuni Shrine. At the very least, a crackdown on anti-foreigner demonstrations doesn’t seem high on the [...]
February 15th, 2010 at 11:59 am