Say what?
A couple of stories that appeared in the news in Japan recently indicate that women here are using the courts to stake out limits on what men should be allowed to say to them.
In the first case, a prefectural assemblyman in Yamanashi, Japan was sentenced to 29 days in jail for calling a woman “fatso,” even though he denied the allegation.
“There’s no way that I called a woman–who is a complete stranger to me–such a word,” Omata told the court.
Omata lodged an appeal against the ruling, reportedly claiming it was “a typical false charge.”
The judge, however, said: “It is hard to play down his responsibility in insulting a woman whom he had met for the first time by picking on a physical characteristic. One can hardly imagine how she felt when she was called ‘fatso’ all of sudden as she was having a pleasant chat with her friends.”
Jail time for name calling?
The other case is a report about a Tokushima University professor who was reprimanded for sending cell phone text messages that included heart emoticons to a female university employee.
The university set up a committee to investigate the case after the staffer complained about the messages.
“She never told me straight that she didn’t want to receive such messages, so I continued to send them to her. But I knew she didn’t want to receive them from her reaction,” he was quoted as saying during the questioning by the committee.
That’s scary. People like Judge Mami Maruo are a threat to liberty in Japan.
January 23rd, 2006 at 6:40 pmI was going to blog on this, but JP beat me to it. The judge’s comments about how he violated her human rights (in the article I read) suggest he knows nothing about human rights, the function of the legal system, or the role of a judge.
January 23rd, 2006 at 7:18 pmI tracked down a Japanese-language article. He called her “debu”, which is hardly something to put someone in jail for.
However, he probably did it, despite his denial. The Japanese article said that a friend he was with also called her a “debu”, but he admitted it. He also got off with a light fine, which makes me wonder what the judge’s problem is.
Both men were in the wrong. Punishment is okay. Someone’s got to learn em and it’s about time. Women have had to put up with male crap for much too long in Japan. Maybe the courts are the only way to highlight the problem and raise conciousness.
January 23rd, 2006 at 7:55 pmWow thats simply crazy. 29days in Jail for name calling? Seriously looks like Japan is going the way of America where everyone is hyper sensitive.
And male shaving prig you think its ok for someone to be put in Jail for a month for name calling? Im sorry but that is insanity.
I really hope it doesn’t end up with people taking everything to the courts in Japan.
January 24th, 2006 at 1:38 amSending someone to jail to highlight a problem is going way too far. Punishment should be justly given based on the crime not some alterior agenda and I’m not sure a single instance of name calling qualifies. In fact I think anyone who goes to the courts because someone called them a fatso has way too much time on their hands. Put some effort into an aspect of women’s rights that actually matters and I would support it.
January 24th, 2006 at 3:48 amEven a fine is absurd. Here in the USA, you know what the law will do to me if call someone a tubbo and she reports me to the police? Absolutely nothing, and rightfully so. Living in a free country requires a thick skin.
January 24th, 2006 at 10:32 amThe more interesting question is how do you prove something like that. Napoleonic Code nonwithstanding, this is pretty whacked.
January 24th, 2006 at 10:54 amI’m having train groper wolf cry flashbacks.
January 24th, 2006 at 9:15 pmIncidentally, that’s the first time that sentence has ever been formed in the english language.:smile:
The scary thing is that if a girl didn’t like you she could simply make it up and get a friend to vouch for her and bam jail time O.o;;
January 26th, 2006 at 10:03 am