Rosie – The video

Here is a video of Rosie O’Donnell doing the bit that has gotten her into hot water with Asians.

23 Responses to “Rosie – The video”

alexpappas Said:

Having seen the video, my opinion is… Big deaaal… :smile:

Darin Said:

Having seen the video, my opinion is…
Look at the mess Mel Gibson got in
Look at the mess Kramer got in

If she doesn’t do at least the same to apologize as they have, then this shows that racism is only racism if the victim is either black or a jew.

Plus, since she’s a big (and I mean not just obese*) anti-anti-gay activist, it’s extra ironic.

She needs to apologize, donate money to some charity that helps the Chinese people that live on dollars a day (because the Chinese government surely can’t be bothered to help it’s own people), and hopefully be taken off the air (however I have alternative motivations for that.)

*Notice I’m not making fun of fat people, just making fun of a fat person. She is making fun of all Chinese people for being Chinese.

Darin Said:

If people want to call to leave a complaint with ABC about this, here is the phone number and directory info for The View.

This information is openly available on ABC’s on website, so I’m not doing anything sneaky, just making it easier for others who want to make their voices heard.

+1 (818) 460-7477 Menu 2>4>849

NB: You’re limited to 30 seconds.

hibiscus Said:

Don’t see what the big deal is, and I’m the group she’s supposed to be making fun of. She was imitating what she ‘thinks’ the Chinese language sounds like, and she thought she was being funny. She wasn’t funny, but I’d hardly call what she did discrimination, just kind of stupid and thoughtless. Nothing to get worked up over. Just my Chinese 2 cents.

sbzoom Said:

This is how you really make fun of Asians:

http://youtouchmywiiwii.ytmnd.com/

Bruce_A Said:

Oh, what a horrible racist. How could she. Blah, blah, blah. What, was it a slow news day when this happened? She wasn’t making fun of Chinese people or the way they talk. She was trying to be funny and not really succeeding.

Next?

Flaffer Said:

I am also surprised with the applause after she said it. Was it that laudable?

Bruce_A Said:

And just so you know, I can’t stand Rosie. I just don’t see what the big deal is.

Supercoolmanchu Said:

hibiscus: I don’t believe your identity.

I’m Asian American and this offends me. 100% of my Asian friends and collegues are mildly to severly offended by this. I think you really have to be Asian having raised in the U.S. to understand, I really do. I feel that no other minority group in the U.S. is so openly mocked on a regular basis as are the “Orientals.” This entire incident made me realize just how far we still have to go as a people. It’s sad that the general “non-Asian” public, even on the “Japundit” forum, fail to recognize how demeaning this really is. Funny or not funny, doesn’t matter. She made a mockery of our identity, period. I guess you really have to grow up as a minority in this country, experience being ridiculed for who you are as a person, in order to be bothered by this “humor.”

It she had stereotypically imitated a black man referencing to the people reacting to Danny DeVito in Africa… just imagine what would happen. Asians are afterall, and always will be, the quiet minority.

Supercoolmanchu Said:

Excuse the typos… Had a couple of Heinekens this evening….:oops:

diamondback Said:

You are absolutely correct SCM.

In the U.S., only groups that go totally bat shit over every real and imagined slight are shown any respect.

overoften Said:

Is that respect or fear?

alexpappas Said:

Look everyone knows… If you want political clout in the United STates, form a group and call a celebrity a racist…

I’m sorry if anyone was offended by this. But come on… If she used a SLUR against Asian PEOPLE by calling them yellow or something of that sort that would be inexcusable…

But seriously if I get my black American accent on here by saying “Damn bitch.. Where’s my friend chicken?”, does THAT make me a racist??

Come on guys, lighten up… No big deal. It was stupid of her, it wasn’t racist…

abu Said:

why are all the rosie apologists viewing this as some kind of isolated incident that occured within the microcosm of some 6 second video clip? by behaving the way she did, this fatass bull dyke was perpetuating a commonly accepted view of chinese people–”this is the way chinese ppl talk, this is how we’ve made fun of them for years”…lets keep it up and maybe congress will pass another Chinese Exclusion Act. I fail to see how a celebrity openly mocking a specific nationality can be deemed acceptable. Rather than lightening up, f**king ppl need to ante up.
on the other hand, i saw the michael richards clip from the laugh factory….now that was f**king hilarious

alexpappas Said:

Abu, I agree with you in that Rosie is a fatass bull dyke…

But if we see a Simpsons Episode where Mister Sparkle is playing, is he makign fun of the Japanese?

I know its not cool what she did, but it doesn’t make her a racist. I’m not a Rosie apologist but I do think we need to lighten up a bit here people. We make Mexican accents all the time, we make fun of black-america’s way of speaking all the time… How is this more unacceptable then the others? When the other things happen we call it comedy. Now suddenly this is racism? Geeze dude, if we can’t laugh at our differences, we’re in big trouble…

Just lighten up already… come on..

abu Said:

alex,
i guess we agree in part on rosie, and in whole on the brilliance of the Mr. Sparkle Simpson’s episode. that being said, i understand the points you are trying to make, but sadly, humor born from parody and satire require some level of education and intelligence–neither of which were present during rosie’s little spout on The View.
so,….hokkaido, eh?

alexpappas Said:

Abu, indeed we can agree on the brilliance of Mr. Sparkle and Rosie.

I do agree that parody and satire require an intelligent point of view to present it properly. Spouting the words she did quite clearly demonstraited her unsophisticated sense of humor.

Of this there can be no denial.

I would simply add that racism, in so much as I understand it, needs to have a sense of thinking lesser of the person. One calls some one a “N****” because he thinks pourly or less of them.

I don’t think that was Rosie’s intention.

RYO Said:

Not to belabor this point, but as an Oriental-Canadian, I should state that Ms. O’Donnell’s comments were mildly offensive. Moreover, her impression cannot rightfully be called an “accent”, insofar as an accent should comprise coherent speech – you know, using real English words spoken with a foreign accent. That said, I acknowledge that context is important. The sting of “ching-chong” style speech is far greater when it is issued with clear malice or spite, which is not the case here. The greater offense, in my opinion, is Ms. O’Donnell’s hypocrisy, given her over-the-top reactions to perceived homophobia.

cloneofsnake Said:

There was a heated conversion over at Gothamist about this yesterday too, and if u look at the comments, u’ll see that New Yorkers are pretty damn racists too!

My first impression to the video was “her face is so fugly I want to puke!“… Personally, I think the way she said it was pretty demeaning to us Chinese, coz that’s exactly how I experience it in my daily life here in NYC. I live in Astoria, which is a pretty hip neighbourhood w/ a mix of old Greek & Italian immigrants and young hippie couples. I’ve gotten Ching Chong’ed at by these Greek / Italian ADULTS!! (Never had that happened to me in Seattle after I left high school!) I found one comment to be pretty well put:

b:your comment reminds me of an incident from a few months ago. i was on broadway, just south of canal, when i walked by a black guy. he said “ching chong” to me (i’m a chinese female) and i thought “if i said ooga booga to you, you’d get upset so why are you saying ching chong to me?”

Jokes are jokes when you understand the truth, and you twist & exaggerate it to make it funny. What she did was no different than the Japanese making fun of gaijins by pretending to suffocate from body odor or something…

Now if you wanna see a really funny mockery of the Chinese language, you gotta see Russell Peters! Drop dead funny!!

cloneofsnake Said:

This is the one. 45 minutes non stop laughing!

Supercoolmanchu Said:

wow… Rosie apologized. I certainly didn’t expect this. Whether the apology was deemed accountable or not, if your actions were hurtful to someone, in this case to hundreds of thousands of people, the moral thing to do is to apologize. It doesn’t matter if you think something you did wasn’t a big deal. You’re only pouring gas on the fire not to mention showing further lack of rectitude by saying to those offended to ‘lighten-up.’ She did the right thing regardless of her intentions.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=T0O_AuhP23E

Amazing what a simple apology can do. Although still obnoxious, now I actually wish her further success on the View.. Just think what a sincere apology could do to a lot of our global abiding altercations between nations.

cloneofskake: thanks for posting that, I sat watching the entire thing LAUGHING MY ASS OFF! I swear I haven’t laughed that hard in a long time. “Anthony by day… TsupsumBong by night!”

Supercoolmanchu Said:

“Who do I make this out to, Ching or Chong?” :razz:

http://youtube.com/watch?v=SYeTSUcVBCo

ROK Drop Links of the Week 11-17DEC06 at ROK Drop Said:

[...] If you haven’t had enough foreigner discrimination in Korea well the Big Hominid broke the story about the Pusan 9 Scandal followed by being blown wide open by the Marmot’s Hole.  The Metropolitician has more on foreigner discrimination by describing how he was targeted by Kyunghyang Shinmun for teaching (gasp!) pro-Japanese propaganda!  How dare he do such a thing?  This independently produced movie isn’t going to help matter either, as it will only confirm what Koreans already believe about ex-pats and worse.  Here is further evidence that Korea and Japan have more in common than they like to admit.  Speaking of foreigner discrimination is Rosie guilty of it too? [...]

Leave a Reply

Design: Dao By Design | Powered by WordPress