Often Overlooked Odawara – Part 2
A Castle Town celebrates its former glory
Related Article: Often Overlooked Odawara – Part 1
Odawara Castle, now a modern reconstruction housing a museum
Towards the end of the 16th Century, the Hojo family of Odawara was one of the strongest clans in war-torn Japan. Through their military victories and adept political maneuvers they had risen from practically a band of highwaymen following a bandit leader to becoming a feared and respected honorable family. But their time was quickly coming to an end even while they were at the height of their prowess.
The Fall of the Hojo
Perhaps it was their victories coupled with their defensive strategies that made the Hojo complacent and arrogant. A new power and a new way of doing things was coming into being beyond their well-defended realm. To the west near modern day Nagoya, the ruthless warlord Oda Nobunaga was working towards the unification of Japan, which was split into many warring territories. Nobunaga was a new breed of warlord who had a vision of uniting Japan under his progressive policies. To achieve this dream, he innovated a number of new techniques that impacted both society and warfare.
Re-creating a scene from Odawara’s illustrious past
Although Nobunaga was assassinated before achieving his dreams, he was succeeded by one of his most brilliant generals, the very capable Toyotomi Hideyoshi. Hideyoshi continued Oda’s master plan and brought much of Japan under his control. All that remained was the northern area of the Tohoku region and the Kanto region. Hideyoshi had little to worry about from Tohoku, but the Kanto region of the Hojo was a vexing concern. The Hojo made very little attempt to acknowledge Hideyoshi’s power, which by now had been officially sanctioned by the Emperor.
The Hojo leader at the time, Ujimasa, failed to realize the times had changed. He failed to understand that Hideyoshi was different from Takeda Shingen and Uesugi Kenshin. When he set out to accomplish something, Hideyoshi rarely gave up. He did not fight battles for the sake of battle itself. In addition, Shingen and Kenshin had been hampered in their attempts to besiege Odawara castle because of their rivalry with each other. Hideyoshi had no rival to distract him in his quest to bring the Hojo under his thumb.
Hideyoshi was a clever man who utilized his innate creativity in a variety of ways to accomplish his goals. He successfully took a castle once by flooding it out with a massive damning project. He did this while keeping the news of Nobunaga’s death from both his enemies and his own men. After concluding this unusual siege, Hideyoshi promptly turned his army around, tracked down his master’s killers, and completely defeated them in battle. Truly, the Hojo had never faced such a resourceful and dedicated opponent before.
Mounted samurai with foot soldier attendant
None of this mattered to the Hojo under Ujimasa. They still saw Hideyoshi as simply the lowly servant to Nobunaga that he once had been and not the brilliant general that he had become. They spurned his offer to come to the capital to tender their respects.
A high-born lady of the Hojo
The Third and Final Siege of Odawara Castle
Hideyoshi, in response, raised one of the largest armies ever assembled in Japan. Over 100,000 soldiers were mobilized in 1590 and sent to besiege Odawara. Faced with such opposing numbers, the Hojo decided to remain in Odawara castle and wait Hideyoshi out, as they had done before with Shingen and Kenshin. They thought such a massive army would soon run out of supplies and starve itself. They had not considered Hideyoshi’s genius for large-scale planning. Hideyoshi’s army was more than well-supplied, and actually enjoyed itself outside the stout walls of Odawara Castle.
The leaders of the Hojo argue while a huge army awaits outside their walls
Normally castle sieges were unpleasant affairs for both besieger and the besieged, but the siege of Odawara resembled more of a town fair than a siege. Hideyoshi provided all manner of entertainment for his troops. He allowed officers to bring their wives and mistresses. Hideyoshi himself had his mistress join him. Vegetable gardens were set up, market stalls were established, and supplies were brought in by ship.
A samurai takes a picture of his lady
The soldiers in Hideyoshi’s army spent their time in poetry parties, tea ceremonies, gambling, cavorting with courtesans, buying, selling, and trading at the numerous shops that had sprung up in the besiegers’ camp. Only the occasional skirmish or raid serve to remind one that there was a war going on. Even these actions were more for relieving boredom than anything else.
A smiling samurai marches off to war
The outcome of the siege was a relatively bloodless event — another rarity in Sengoku siege warfare, where the besieged often starved to death, killed themselves, or mounted suicidal last-stand charges. The Hojo leadership reluctantly realized Hideyoshi was not going anywhere and that eventually their stocks would be depleted. They surrendered after three months.
Hideyoshi did not wish for a bloodbath, so the besieged were spared save for Ujimasa and his brother. Technically the fifth ruler of the Hojo was Ujimasa’s son Ujinao, but his retired father was the one who really ran the show and so Ujinao was surprisingly spared. His father and uncle were required to commit seppeku — ritual suicide.
Female samurai wearing horo, which was worn for protection and identification
Their deaths mark the closing chapter of the Sengoku Period. Hideyoshi had done the unimaginable and united Japan after more than a century of warfare. With the exception of a few finishing touches towards unification, the next time Japanese warriors would fight on Japanese soil would be in the great Sekigahara campaign in 1600, but they would do so in two great unified armies. The chaotic days of Hojo Soun with numerous clans fighting and vying for power were over.
Ladies of the Old Japan
Odawara Today
Odawara can be reached from Tokyo from both the Tokkaido Line and Odakyu Line. A short walk from the station leads to the old castle ground, the main attraction of Odawara. The castle is a modern reconstruction, like so many castles throughout Japan. Although it survived Hideyoshi’s siege, the castle did not survive the wave of destruction that many castles suffered in the late 19th Century as Japan moved forward towards modernization.
The castle was rebuilt in the 1960s with a modern interior which now houses a museum of samurai armor and other artifacts from the castle’s history. The top of the castle offers great views of the surrounding area and the ocean. On clear days one can spot Mount Fuji. Admission is just under US$4.
A small menagerie is located on the grounds in the shadow of the main keep. Various birds, monkeys, deer, and one small elephant comprise the inhabitants of this small zoo. The sight of the animals is small cages may depress more than delight, however. The grounds are free.
Hojo Dave and the Odawara Elephant
Odawara Celebrates Its Former Glory
Odawara, the once great city of the Kanto region, declined over the centuries. Yet on May 3rd every year, like ghosts summoned from across the void, armor-clad samurai, spear-toting footmen, mounted warriors, and elegant noble ladies appear to reclaim their lost glory. The Hojo Godai festival allows the citizens of Odawara to relive their city’s great past through an impressive historical procession.
A Mikoshi bearer stops to answer a phone call
The procession marches through the castle’s lower gate, across the moat, and through parts of the city’s street before coming together under the castle walls. There they hold a kind of rally that one might have seen over 400 years ago whenever the Hojo marched to war — which was fairly often. Some of the musket-bearing samurai fire off their old guns on the moat bridge.
Several mikoshi — portable shrines — are toted about by shouting sweaty men. When they reach the gathering spot the men gather up their energy and race forward with their heavy burden.
Grandfatherly Samurai wearing prescription shades
With the marching bands and the eyeglass-wearing samurai, the procession is a kind of mix of a hometown parade and a large procession of extras walking off the set of a Kurosawa film at the end of the day.
A little samurai marches off to battle admist the sighs and ‘aww’s of grandmothers
Odawara’s Legacy
Technically-speaking, Odawara did not impact Japan’s destiny directly. It was through the fall of the Hojo that a chain of events was set into motion that would affect not only Japan but also the world.
With the Hojo defeated, there was no one left in Japan to oppose Toyotomi Hideyoshi and so he cast his lusty eyes further afield. Within two years he launched a vainglorious and ultimately disastrous military campaign in Korea in a mad attempt to push through the country and conqueror China. His forces never made it out of Korea despite a second massive invasion a few years later. His actions sowed the seeds of animosity between the two countries, particularly in Korea, which suffered greatly from these destructive invasions.
Colorful samurai with halbred
Back in Japan, the invasions weakened loyalty to the Toyotomi clan and a crafty leader quickly exploited the situation following Hideyoshi’s death in 1598. This was Tokugawa Ieyasu who fought at the siege of Odawara. And here was the second major impact that Odawara’s fall had on Japan, and perhaps the most important.
As a reward for his services, Hideyoshi offered Ieyasu the Kanto domain of the Hojo in exchange for Ieyasu’s old lands, which were uncomfortably close to Hideyoshi’s powerbase. Ieyasu accepted the offer and chose for his capital a little old town of small value known as Edo. In 1603, he was named Shogun after defeating Toyotomi supporters three years earlier at Sekigahara. As a result, the city of Edo swiftly grew in size as the new seat of government. And in 1867, when the Emperor transfered his residence to Edo, the city was renamed Tokyo. So in short, without the rise of the Odawara Hojo and their subsequent fall, there would be no Tokyo as it is today.
Hojo Warlord makes his entrance
I disagree with the statement that the venture into Korea was vainglorious. Many historians believe it was in fact a shrewd tactic intended to dispose of the many professional warriors who had no place in a recently-unified and peaceful Japan. Pressured by the demands for payment, Hideyoshi likely sent his whinging and increasingly dissatisfied troops to die on foreign soil. The notion of conquering mighty China was likely nothing more than a pretense, as it was a patently ludicrous proposition.
June 15th, 2007 at 7:43 pm“believe to be” and “is” are two different things especially when gifted with hindsight.
Hideyoshi was following the plan of his master Oda Nobunaga who also wanted to tackle China once he unified Japan but he was killed before that could happen.
And the shrewdness idea doesn’t exactly explain the second massive invasion. He ended up creating division in Japan which ultimately led to the downfall of his house.
June 15th, 2007 at 11:23 pmHideyoshi offered the Kanto region to Tokugawa Ieyasu as a way to remove Ieyasu from his traditional power base in central Japan. Ieyasu knew what Hideyoshi was trying to do, but accepted the offer, and went about draining marshland and turning a small village (Edo) into a large castle town. When, for whatever reasons, Hideyoshi decided to launch his invasions of Korea, Ieyasu was able to get out of contributing troops on the grounds he needed the manpower for the construction work going on in Edo. Thus, when the Korean campaigns finally came to an end with Hideyoshi’s death, Tokugawa Ieyasu was in a strong position to take over, which he did soon after. The rest, as they say, is history.
Good article, though I still think when it comes to Odawara, it’s a case of making the proverbial silk purse out of the proverbial sow’s ear.
June 15th, 2007 at 11:59 pmYou seem to have some bug up the proverbial butt about Odawara. Historical appreciation rather than negative indifference would be a better approach.
Besides on May 3rd, Odawara is worthy of stepping out of the station for a gander.
June 16th, 2007 at 12:40 am“You seem to have some bug up the proverbial butt about Odawara”.
One man’s bug is another man’s obsession, I suppose.
I lived for 18 months in Yokkaichi in Mie-ken. It’s a city with an interesting history, a fun matsuri in late July/early August, and in general, a good place to live. But there’s virtually nothing of interest there for the casual visitor, and it wouldn’t have hurt my feelings one bit if people preferred to continue on to Ise, for example, rather than stop in Yokkaichi to see a stretch of the old Tokaido highway.
I’ve been to Odawara on several occasions. Like many places in Japan, it looks like it would be a nice city to live. I appreciate the it’s role in Japanese history (as you might know if you read the first part of my previous comment). I just think there’s a reason why Odawara is seldom mentioned in travel books (even Japanese-language guides), except as a place in passing.
I’ve always had a soft spot in my heart for Takasaki, in Gumma-ken. It’s never bothered me that few other people share the same feelings. Don’t feel so down just because other people don’t share your enthusiasm for Odawara.
BTW, does the castle still have that sad zoo on its grounds? If so, you should try channeling your energy into either improving the conditions of the animals there, or getting rid of it entirely.
June 16th, 2007 at 9:28 am“It’s a city with an interesting history, a fun matsuri in late July/early August, and in general, a good place to live. But there’s virtually nothing of interest there for the casual visitor…”
You’ve pretty much captured the essence of Canada as a tourist destination with this statement.
June 16th, 2007 at 9:48 amI just think there’s a reason why Odawara is seldom mentioned in travel books (even Japanese-language guides), except as a place in passing.
That’s because the guidebook writers can’t appreciate it. I’m not saying it’s the next best thing to sliced bread but simply that if one looks at Odawara in a different light, they may come to appreciate it more rather than disdaining so readily out of hand due to some blase comments in a guidebook.
I could have written about Kyoto, Nikko, or some other overwritten spot but I chose a spot that many people take for granted to show that overlooked spots have their own special charm. Looking at things in a new light should always be encouraged.
June 17th, 2007 at 1:00 am“Looking at things in a new light should always be encouraged.”
Agreed. You’ve written a very good article, and contributed some great photos to go with it.
“…they may come to appreciate it more rather than disdaining so readily out of hand due to some blase comments in a guidebook.”
True. But I didn’t need a guidebook to tell me Odawara is just OK – I’ve been there myself. (If it’s any consolation, the Lonely Planet guide does say the castle is nice to visit during the cherry blossom season).
When was Japan’s greatest period of castle construction? The 1960’s, when so many were reconstructed (in concrete, and some with elevators) in order to bring in the tourists. Call me a purist, but I’d prefer to visit one of the dozen original Japanese castles still standing. Everyone knows about Himeji or Matsumoto, but others like Hikone or Inuyama don’t get as much print in the guidebooks.
June 17th, 2007 at 9:42 amI really do hope that wretched zoo goes soon. And I have very little time for concrete castles, especially since they usually cost about the same as Himeji. There is no Japanese city that is totally bereft of tourist interest, but in the limited time that most people have to get around the country, Odawara rates pretty low. Historically, as the home of the Hojo and the gateway to the Kanto, it is of some interest, but really, when you have one to two weeks, there are a lot better things to see.
June 17th, 2007 at 3:34 pmNo doubt, Overthinker. Odawara is not for that kind of two trip BUT as in the case with my parents first trip which was so brief, Odawara can be a change of pace from the temples and shrines of Kanto if you don’t have time to reach Matsumoto which is a far superior castle.
Odawara is more of a daytrip for the longterm resident which can be combined with a visit to Kamakura or as a stopping point on the way to Izu or Fuji.
As for the zoo, they should change it or can it especially for the elephant’s sake.
June 17th, 2007 at 7:40 pmI think that the role for Odawara you suggest can then be reasonably filled by any decent-sized town – ideally the one you live in, even if it’s Tokyo (say you live half an hour out on a suburban line: that’s plenty ‘quiet’ for a change of pace). Would make a good lunch spot for a leisurely one-night trip out to Fuji or Izu though.
Matsumoto is an easy day trip from Tokyo (I have done it myself, albeit almost twenty years ago) and I would rate the castle as vastly superior if castles are what you are interested in.
June 17th, 2007 at 10:34 pmI think that the role for Odawara you suggest can then be reasonably filled by any decent-sized town – ideally the one you live in,
Uh, no then you’d be missing the whole point of my two part article.
Not any old decent town has:
1) A Castle even a reconstructed one where the largest army in Japan was once assembled to besiege it and which was the headquarters for a century of one of the most prominent Sengoku families
– for those interested in Japanese history particulary the Sengoku Period, Odawara would be ideal spot to visit.
2) a historical parade which effectively uses the castle as a backdrop – they also fire off old guns on the bridge.
3) a chance to try on Samurai armor for only 200 yen and get your photo taken in said armor in front of the castle.
Matsumoto is not an easyday trip moneywise if you take the shinkansen. On the cheap, it’s 3 hours by bus. I’ve been there twice.
Matsumoto is a great castle but it’s history pales in comparison with Odawara.
June 17th, 2007 at 10:59 pmThe role you suggested that I referred to was the ‘change of pace’ from the temples and shrines (and thus the implied tourism overload) you referred to with your parents and other short-term visitors. I do not disagree about the interest for the long-termer, but suspect rather than the deep historical aspects which would be of minimal interest to the casual visitor, especially since the castle is a concrete shell and there is little else remaining.
The historical parade could be interesting but requires careful timing. And most foreign visitors (which was how I was reading your later posts especially, talking about your parents) would use (or would benefit greatly from) a Japan Rail pass, thereby making the price difference moot.
An interesting question is the importance of historical “sites” versus “sights” for visiting foreign countries. Will people be impressed if you show them a steel factory or something and say “this was where the Battle of Nagakude was fought,” or would they appreciate a more tactile and visual encounter that might not be as significant historically?
The samurai armour thing could be fun, for the chance not only to try it on but more importantly for the backdrop.
Perhaps I am biased – on my one and only trip to the castle I was so angered by the dismal excuse for a zoo on the grounds that perhaps the city became tainted by extension – it became “that city with the awful zoo (and the nasty concrete castle).” But nevertheless I’m not sure that your average tourist is going to be that enthralled when there are more spectacular, if perhaps less historical, sights to see, and I have already agreed that it would make a good stop-off spot for local trips from Tokyo.
June 18th, 2007 at 12:14 amWell, you certainly live up to your handle’s namesake –
You and kaminoge have presented the conventional view of places like Odawara which is basically summed up like so many guidebooks on the place as simply “not much of interest.”
If I felt that way, I would never have bothered to write a two-part article arguing to the contrary of that blase and apparently strongly-held opinion.
It’s a glass half-empty verus a glass half-full perspective.
It’s all about cultural awareness and historical appreciation. Without either, Odawara is boring and not worth a gander while Himeji and Kyoto offer up amazing sights which require little effort from viewers to be easily placated like placid cattle in lush green fields.
But even these sights become richer with the knowing.
What makes Odawara interesting and worth a gander is its depth but it’s something a person has to make the effort to see and understand. On the surface, it’s just another non-descript town along the tokkaido-sen to Kyoto with a dismal zoo and a concrete castle. But it has a hidden depth that once scratched leads to a very fascinating story about the Hojo and the destiny of Japan.
June 18th, 2007 at 1:02 am“Well, you certainly live up to your handle’s namesake”
I chose it as I was accused of “overthinking” an issue in one forum….
Most tourists are basically placid cattle, mind you.
June 18th, 2007 at 9:31 amBTW, my favourite “needs knowledge to appreciate otherwise it’s very dull” site is the Mound of Ears in Kyoto. That was cool.
The mound of ears, I take it, was a “gift” of all the Korean ears removed from the slain during Toyotomi’s invasion? Where is that exactly? Next time I’m Kyoto, I’d like to check it out.
June 18th, 2007 at 10:27 pmIt’s in Higashi-ku, in front of the Toyokuni Shrine (itself worthy of some attention, since despite looking drab to the average tourist, it enshrines none other than Toyotomi Hideyoshi and its gate, a National Treasure, was once part of his Fushimi Castle and is a rare example of Momoyama gate design and may well have even come from Jurakudai, since much of Jurakudai was reassembled at Fushimi). It has signs in Japanese and Korean.
June 18th, 2007 at 11:29 pm[...] Century, the Hojo family of Odawara was one of the strongest clans in war-torn Japan source: Often Overlooked Odawara Part 2, [...]
October 23rd, 2007 at 4:17 pmLooks like this letter writer to the Japan Times http://search.japantimes.co.jp/cgi-bin/rc20080518a7.html failed to appreciate both the reconstructed castle, and the history behind it!
May 22nd, 2008 at 9:28 am