Timothy Harada: Japan-U.S. Stereotypes
Timothy Harada, a musician whose music we have played on the Japan Talk pocast, has written something titled “Contrasting US and Japanese steretypes of each other Before, During and After World War II” for the the Sendai Voice.
Before, during and after World War II, the stereotypes Japanese held of United States (US) citizens and the stereotypes US citizens held of Japanese citizens changed drastically. At a certain time before World War II, some Japanese held a neutral feeling about people from the US, while others held a positive view of US citizens and US culture. In the US, compared to other Asian nationalities, there were many positive feelings about Japanese citizens as well. Leading up to World War II, however, the US government and US writers created myths that all Japanese were despotically ruled, automatons, who would do anything for the glory of their emperor-that they were the new eastern imperialists. In response, Japanese writers began to create myths that all people from the US were evil, barbarous, imperialists as well. Nonetheless, directly after World War II was over, these myths changed drastically. Amazingly, the negative stereotypes held on both sides changed into positive stereotypes almost overnight. Over the last half of a century, the stereotypes on both sides have oscillated back and forth, between good, neutral and bad, due to many varied circumstances. What caused such drastic changes in stereotypes between citizens of the US and of Japan? What can be done to insure that people of different cultures maintain positive images of one another? What can be done to insure that peace is maintained between the US and Japan?
well i’m defiantly out of my Deppth on this..but, I think that similar sentiments have been expressed by Uncle Gil over at…(be careful remora!..)
http://nikkeiview.com/nv/archives04/021604.htm
*hey? where’s everybody else? or has Golden Week sent you commenteer’s into a coma-like state of keyboard paralysis..*
yours
(off-to-Church-now)
remora
May 4th, 2008 at 7:27 amIt’s an interesting article. I think he underestimates how much anti-West (especially the US and it’s cultural influence) sentiment there was all through the late 1800s and the first half of the 1900s. It didn’t just suddenly appear in the late 1930s. Things like the Triple Intervention convinced many Japanese that they’d never be treated fairly by the West. Cultural things like the modern girl (seen as a result of Western cultural influence) also worried some Japanese for how they believed it broke down traditional Japanese society and gender roles.
May 5th, 2008 at 12:34 amI actually didn’t look at any time prior to World War II, because I was only interested in how stereotypes are used to justify wars with other countries. I think we see the same thing with stereotypes now toward Muslims and other people who have been labeled as ‘terrorists’ by the US and others who want to create an enemy to justify wars and continued war spending.
May 8th, 2008 at 10:29 pm