We Japanese. . .
07/08/2008 @ 12:00 am
What Japan Thinks has a report on an Internet survey about what Japanese people think are the greatest attributes of Japan and the Japanese people.
The top 10 responses. . .
1. A sense of the four seasons
2. Diligence
3. Kindness
4. Rich food culture
5. Ability to create cutting-edge technology
6. Courteousness
7. Strong sense of duty
8. Consideration of others
9. Flexibility in adopting new cultures
10. Manual dexterity
Other notables further down the list are “Ability to express things vaguely,” “Ability to distinguish between subtle differences in taste,” and “Good table manners.”
Ability to express things vaguely should be in the fucking top, damn it.
July 8th, 2008 at 2:22 amI actually agree with most of them except 9 and 10. Plus, #1 is pretty lame. It seems they feel Japan is unique in its four seasons and that other countries don’t have them.
July 8th, 2008 at 5:17 ami want to know who spoon these answers to the survey respondents, because this smells like a survey designed to bolster pre-conceived notions that people have of japan. do they provide open surveys or just force people to choose from a list of choices they don’t agree with? was there a write in section? or a “i find this whole exercise incredibly offensive and lacking in options of characteristics i actually admire about this nation?”
but just in case this survey is on the up and up, my thoughts if it were true:
you know your country must be lame when polls indicate that the majority of the population says their ability to detect changes in temperature and whether deciduous trees are growing green leaves or dropping them as their nation’s best characteristic.
i mean seriously, what else are you proud of at that point?
“look, i can count to ten on my fingers”
“most of us can wipe our asses without assistance”
“last night when i fell asleep, my heart kept beating, and was still doing so this morning”
“our people can procreate through mating”
“when i’m hungry and there’s food around, i generally eat before i starve to death”
congratulations, the majority of you aren’t mentally disabled paraplegics!
but maybe it is a differentiation that the japanese notice seasonal changes more than those from other countries. i mean, who (that isn’t japanese) can honestly say that they haven’t gone out in july dressed in a winter coat, ski pants, gloves, boots, and a beanie over full body wool underwear with a snow shovel to clear our driveway? wait a minute, except for those stationed in antarctica, i suspect the answer is no one.
insect and birds of doing the same.
i know the country holds itself in high esteem, but what delusion are they operating under? do they think their country isn’t on planet earth? or are they under the impression that functioning central nervous systems and cerebrums are just a part of the japanese dna?
to summarize i shall paraphrase a quote from penn:
“why do people do polls anyway? why should you gave a f*ck what other people think? the only things that matter are right, wrong, and the reasoning you use to determine your answers.”
July 8th, 2008 at 4:40 pmedits
spoon fed
July 8th, 2008 at 4:42 pminsects and birds can do the same thing
Notice that there is no mention of freedom anywhere on this list.
“but maybe it is a differentiation that the japanese notice seasonal changes more than those from other countries. i mean, who (that isn’t japanese) can honestly say that they haven’t gone out in july dressed in a winter coat, ski pants, gloves, boots, and a beanie over full body wool underwear with a snow shovel to clear our driveway?”
Actually, the rest of the world probably has Japan beat on this. The Japanese are the ones who like to start wearing long-sleeved shirts and pants when Fall officially starts, even though it’s usually still scorching hot outside. Somehow they fail to notice that in most of Japan it might as well be summer for six months out of the year.
July 8th, 2008 at 11:06 pmI believe most of these polls are from an online site, so its self selecting and the sampling isn’t random. Take it with a grain of salt and as a moment of amusement or as a conversation/argument starter.
July 9th, 2008 at 1:48 amThere’s no mention of freedom because the Japanese aren’t spoon-fed the notion of freedom as Americans are. But that’s probably a good thing to point out. People respond to these sorts of questions with the generalities they have been taught.
I hope you don’t mean that not actually citing “freedom” means that they have less of it – any more than citing it would mean that they have more of it.
Stalinist Russia and Mao’s China were filled with slogans that touted the opposite of what the people really had.
I wish more people would ask themselves what freedom means. For example, people in China today are in some respects (obviously not all), more free than Americans.
I wouldn’t be able to say who is more free between the Japanese and the Americans. Depends on the definition. Certainly they are more free to do what they want without being sued into poverty, or arrested for insensitivity, or hounded to death by the tax bureau. Just those three off the top of my head.
July 9th, 2008 at 8:14 amWith the exception of 4, and maybe 7, all I can think of are the glaring exceptions to the others.
When I grew up, I thought the Americans invented the steam engine, the German’s invented the printing press, and the brontosaurus was a real creature (all the scientists and our text books said so).
So everybody grows up with some well-instilled self-images the way computers come with Windows Explorer. You can change it, but most people don’t even think about it.
I’m still shattered about losing the brontosaurus.
July 9th, 2008 at 8:23 am“When I look back on all the crap I learned in high school, it’s a wonder I can think at all…
“Mama don’t take my brontosaur,
July 9th, 2008 at 11:14 am“Mama don’t take my brontosaur,
“Mama don’t take my brontosaur away…
” Ability to express things vaguely ” ???
No, that should mean ” Ability to express things negative without giving negative impression, so that you sometimes don’t notice it was negative. “
July 10th, 2008 at 1:15 amInstant Rammen never made the list. Oh, yeah that guy was Chinese that discovered instant rammen. Or was he Chinese?
“We do Compact” never made the list too.
July 10th, 2008 at 9:11 amI didn’t know he was a Chinese.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Momofuku_Ando
I agree with ” We do Compact ” such as Netsuke, Bonsai, Origami, Traditional Tea Ceremony Room, Capsule Hotel, Walkman …
July 10th, 2008 at 9:52 amI actually agree with #9. Yeah, i have met stubborn nationalistic Japanese people, but I will use history as my base for my argument. The best examples are Japan throwing away samurai cultures, adopting british political system, and of course opening up ports for foreign goods relatively a lot earlier than most other asian nations.
Yes, I’m Japanese so I am biased, but I’m not trying to say that Japan is better than other asian nations. I have a lot of criticism against Japan, with politics obviously being one of them. Anyways, currently since citizens of Japan are becoming more and more retarded (women don’t want to become housewives, children not taking education seriously, and men becoming more absorbed to sex industry more than ever), so Japan’s relying on foreign immigrants for future developments. The irony is that Japan’s stubborness(strictness?) to the immigration system.
Regardless, I still believe what makes Japan Japan is indeed the ability to accept other cultures a lot further than into their pop culture.
July 10th, 2008 at 5:34 pmI don’t think Japanese are more against foreigners than other countries whenever they speak fluent Japanese. The major obstacle is about the immigration system.
When time comes Japan has to rely on foreign immigrants for industrial labor forces, it will probably change as well.
July 10th, 2008 at 9:51 pm